The History of Workers’ Compensation in Pennsylvania

Workers’ Compensation Before 1915

At the beginning of the 20th century, employees did not have workers’ compensation in Pennsylvania. During that era, an employee’s only legal recourse after a workplace injury was to establish negligence through tort law, which proved far more challenging in practice than in theory.

Legal proceedings were often stacked in favor of employers, who could avoid liability in many circumstances.

One issue was that an employee could not win their case if they were found to be at fault for the accident. An even more significant obstacle was the fact that employees also could not recover if a fellow employee was responsible for the accident.

A saving grace for workers did exist in that these cases were often heard before juries. Juries of the time were frequently pro-labor and occasionally awarded large verdicts to injured employees. This created an unpredictable system where employers were rarely held liable, but when they were, the consequences could be substantial.

The Workers’ Compensation Act of 1915

Everything changed in 1915 when the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania passed the Workers’ Compensation Act of 1915.

The Act established a compromise in which employers assumed liability for workplace injuries regardless of fault. In exchange, employers received immunity from most workplace injury lawsuits.

Under the Act, workers were generally protected so long as:

• They were an employee
• The injury arose in the course of employment
• The injury and disability were causally related to work

The Act also established the benefits available to injured workers, including wage-loss benefits and payment of medical expenses.

In addition, it created a dispute resolution system administered by the Pennsylvania Department of Labor & Industry and presided over by workers’ compensation judges. This provided employers with greater predictability while giving injured workers access to a specialized system designed to resolve workplace injury claims.

Major Changes to Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Law

Since its inception, the Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Act has evolved through court decisions and legislative amendments.

Occupational Disease Act of 1937

In 1937, Pennsylvania expanded protections for workers by recognizing occupational diseases under the Occupational Disease Act.

The law provided benefits for workers suffering from conditions such as black lung disease and other illnesses caused by workplace exposure. Today, more than 35 occupational diseases are covered under Pennsylvania workers’ compensation law.

The 1972 Amendments

Workers’ compensation protections expanded significantly in 1972.

These amendments:

• Increased weekly benefit rates
• Expanded workers’ rights regarding medical treatment
• Restructured the dispute resolution process
• Changed the compensable event from an “accident” to an “injury”

This final change dramatically expanded the scope of workers’ compensation coverage.

Expansion of the Definition of Injury

In 1987, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court defined an injury as any “adverse and hurtful change.”

This interpretation broadened workers’ compensation protections and expanded the types of injuries that could qualify for benefits.

Reforms Beginning in 1993

Beginning in 1993, several amendments focused on controlling costs within the workers’ compensation system.

One major change introduced utilization reviews and fee caps designed to ensure that medical treatment remained reasonable and necessary.

Compromise and Release Settlements

In 1996, Pennsylvania amended the Workers’ Compensation Act to allow compromise and release settlements.

These settlements gave injured workers and insurance companies the ability to resolve claims through negotiated agreements.

The settlement process was further expanded in 2006 through the introduction of mandatory mediation, which encouraged earlier resolution of disputed claims.

How Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Continues to Evolve

The history of workers’ compensation in Pennsylvania reflects more than a century of legal developments designed to balance the interests of injured workers and employers.

From the passage of the Workers’ Compensation Act of 1915 to the expansion of occupational disease protections and modern settlement procedures, the law has continued to evolve to address changing workplaces and workforce needs.

Today, Pennsylvania workers’ compensation remains an essential system that provides wage-loss benefits, medical coverage, and other protections to workers who suffer work-related injuries and illnesses.

Talk to a Pennsylvania Workers’ Compensation Attorney Today

If you or a loved one has been hurt at work, Stern & Cohen can help. Our Pennsylvania workers’ compensation attorneys assist injured workers throughout Philadelphia and across Pennsylvania in pursuing the benefits they deserve.

Contact Stern & Cohen today for a free consultation.

FAQs